High Quality Ingredients
We use high quality ingredients in all our pizzas to ensure that our customers can get the best out of it. Not only does it taste the absolute best, but also you can be assured that the quality is without par.
Amazing good food that fits your taste!
We serve pizza that is outrageously delicious! We take great pride that our creations are unique and each of them fits perfectly to your discriminating tastes.
Order From Our Website
Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.
What our guests are saying
This is the best pizza in Atlanta! We randomly stumbled across this place and have not looked back since. I’m so shocked at how fresh and delicious it is EVERY SINGLE TIME! You will not be disappointed with Goodfellas.
Nyia M.
Good fellas will make your pizza exactly the way you like it. It is another one of the best pizza joint out there. Good customer service, very tasty and delicious. And let’s not forget you become a member and they send you discounts to your email enjoy.
Stephanie D.
Wow, the calzones here are so so good! The dough is excellent and the mozzarella they use is so good and cheesy without being overly greasy. I look forward to the next time I can eat here.
Mike
Goodfellas Pizza Rewards
Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.
About Us
Discover for yourself why Goodfellas is such a big hit for pizza cravings for over 14 years! We've already expanded. Find your favorite new menu item here- from our very own house pizza (think of an upgrade to your traditional supreme versions), to our wings or jalapenos poppers- you'll be a forever fan!"
Our Gallery
Featuring
Gluten-Free Options
Healthy Options
Easy Parking
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for Chili, Garlic Bread, Stromboli, Fried Chicken, Calzone, Italian Food, Turkey Burger, Burgers, Meat Lovers Pizza, Cobb Salad, Caesar Salad, Hawaiian Pizza, Grilled Chicken, Chicken Alfredo, Lemonade, Pasta, Cheese Pizza, Vegetarian Food, Burger, Hot Wings, Chicken Tenders, Cheese Burger, Cheese Steak, Calzones, Veggie Burgers, Fries, BBQ, Chicken Salad, Pepperoni Pizza, Salads, Pan Pizza, Philly Cheese Steak, Wings, Cheese Bread, French Fries, American Food, Meatballs, Veggie Burger, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, and Greek Salad
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: Royal Terrace, Lake Park Estates, Lake Forest Hills, Carver Manor, Biscayne Village, Langmar, Edgewood Manor, Lake Forest Manor, Harborview, Ribault, Jacksonville, Sherwood Forrest, Magnolia Gardens, Cambon, Picketville, Osceola Forrest, Royal Terrace, Pearl Court, Lake Forrest Hills, Allendale.
