Goodfellas Pizza and Wings Menu

Fried Mozzarella (6)

Six golden-fried sticks of premium mozzarella cheese. Crispy on the outside, perfectly melted on the inside. Every bite of this Goodfellas favorite comes with a side of zesty marinara.

Jalapeño Poppers

Six spicy, cheesy, and addictive poppers. Stuffed with cream cheese and jalapeños, these fiery bites are a perfect bold starter from the Goodfellas kitchen.

Cheese Bread w/Sauce

Goodfellas signature Cheese Bread. Warm, gooey, and covered in a blend of melted cheeses, served with a side of our fresh marinara sauce for dipping. A classic starter done the Goodfellas way.

Garlic Bread w/Sauce

Freshly baked bread brushed with savory garlic butter and herbs, toasted to a perfect golden crisp. It's the simple, delicious classic you crave—only at Goodfellas Pizza.

Small Fries

A small order of our perfectly seasoned, crispy French fries. The ideal salty side to any Goodfellas combo or sandwich.

Large Fries

A generous portion of our hot, golden, and crispy French fries. Great for sharing with the whole table while you wait for your main course at Goodfellas Pizza.

Pepperoni

Slices of savory, smoky, and slightly spicy cured meat that cups up and crisps beautifully. The classic pizza topping, done right by Goodfellas.

Ham

Thinly sliced, savory, and tender cooked ham. A perfect pairing with pineapple on our Super Hawaiian or added to any meaty creation.

Italian Sausage

Crumbled, perfectly seasoned pork sausage with fennel and herbs, adding a rich, aromatic flavor to any Goodfellas pie.

Beef Sausage

Finely ground, seasoned beef sausage that adds a savory depth and texture. A favorite addition to our fully-loaded Goodfellas Special.

Chicken

Tender, all-white grilled chicken breast pieces. Lean, flavorful, and great on our Buffalo Chicken or any custom pizza.

Bacon

Crispy, chopped pieces of salty, irresistible smoked bacon. A welcome, smoky crunch on any Goodfellas Pizza or Stromboli.

Steak

Thinly sliced, seasoned steak pieces, marinated and cooked until tender. The star topping of our decadent Steak & Cheese Pizza.

Onions

Sliced yellow onions that caramelize beautifully under the heat, providing a savory depth to any Goodfellas Pizza.

Bell Peppers

Fresh, colorful strips of crisp Green Bell Pepper that add a refreshing, sweet crunch to your custom Goodfellas pie.

Banna Peppers

Sliced, mild yellow peppers that add a bright, tangy pop and a little bit of heat. A unique, zesty favorite.

Jalapenos

Thinly sliced, fiery jalapeños that bring a significant, fresh heat to your custom Goodfellas Pizza.

Green Olives

Sliced, tangy, and salty green olives. A bolder flavor choice that adds a wonderful brine to our Vegetarian and Goodfellas Special pizzas.

Black Olives

Sliced, mild, and buttery black olives. A Mediterranean staple that adds a salty, savory layer to any Goodfellas combination.

Mushrooms

Sliced, earthy mushrooms that absorb the rich flavors of the sauce and cheese. A classic vegetable topping.

Feta Cheese

Crumbled, bold, and salty white feta cheese. A signature topping on our Greek Salad and a zesty upgrade for any pizza or calzone.

3 Cheese

Our house blend of Mozzarella, Provolone, and Parmesan. Upgrade your cheese experience for a richer flavor profile on any pie.

Pineapple

Sweet, juicy chunks of tropical pineapple. A controversial yet delicious pairing with ham or pepperoni on your Goodfellas pizza.

Lettuce

A blend of fresh, crisp green leaf and Romaine lettuce. The perfect foundation for any delicious Goodfellas salad.

Parmesan Cheese

Grated, aged Italian cheese with a sharp, salty flavor. The perfect finishing touch for any salad, pasta, or sub.

Cucumbers

Freshly sliced, cool, and crisp green cucumbers. Essential for our Garden and Fried Chicken salads.

Red Onions

Thinly sliced red onions that offer a sharper, more piquant flavor than our regular onions. Great for salads and the Greek Salad.

Perreroncini Peppers

Mild, tangy, and zesty whole golden peppers. A delicious and colorful addition to our Greek Salad and other dishes.

Spinach

Fresh, bright green leaf spinach. A healthy and flavorful addition to any pizza or our Spinach & Feta Calzone.

Crutons

Crispy, savory seasoned bread pieces. Adds a satisfying, buttery crunch to our Caesar Salad and other green feasts.

All Drums Per 5 Wings

Love the meatier drums? Upgrade your Goodfellas wings to All Drums today.

All Flats Per 5 Wings

Prefer the flats? Upgrade your Goodfellas wings to All Flats for a minimal charge.

Blue Cheese

Dip your Goodfellas wings in a side of bold Blue Cheese dressing.

Pizza Slice And Drink

A quick, hot slice of our classic Cheese Pizza served with a Fountain Drink. The ideal fast Goodfellas lunch on the go.

10” Cheese Pizza

A timeless classic. Our fresh pizza sauce and a perfect blanket of mozzarella cheese baked on our crispy crust. Simple, delicious, and always satisfying from Goodfellas Pizza.

10” Three Cheese Pizza

Elevate the classic with extra flavor! We combine fresh mozzarella, provolone, and parmesan cheeses for a rich, savory experience only at Goodfellas.

10” Steak and Cheese

A Philly-inspired pie! Topped with thinly sliced, Marinated Steak, caramelized onions, and a blend of Mozzarella and Provolone Cheese. A savory masterpiece from Goodfellas.

10” Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Bold and zesty! Features tender Chicken tossed in our tangy Buffalo Sauce, fresh mozzarella, and finished with authentic Blue Cheese Crumbles. A fiery favorite at Goodfellas Pizza.

10" Combination (3 Toppings) Pizza

Your pie, your way! Choose any three of our Goodfellas premium toppings to create the perfect personalized pizza.

10” Goodfellas Special Pizza

The boss of all pies! This signature pizza is loaded with Beef, Ham, Italian Sausage, Onions, Olives, Tomatoes, and Feta Cheese. It's the ultimate, fully-loaded pie—only from Goodfellas Pizza!

10" House Special Pizza

A complete flavor package with Beef, Ham, Italian Sausage, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, and Black Olives. A true traditional combo that the Goodfellas kitchen does best.

10” Pepperoni Pizza

Generous slices of bold Pepperoni layered over our house sauce and cheese. A universal favorite, perfectly cooked every time by Goodfellas Pizza.

10” Super Hawaiian Pizza

A bold debate starter! Topped with savory Ham, sliced Pepperoni, and chunks of sweet Pineapple. Find out why this is a surprisingly delicious favorite at Goodfellas.

10” Vegetarian Pizza

A fresh, garden-topped pizza featuring Onions, Peppers, Mushrooms, Black & Green Olives, Tomatoes, and Feta Cheese. The crisp, delicious choice at Goodfellas Pizza.

14” Cheese Pizza

A timeless classic. Our fresh pizza sauce and a perfect blanket of mozzarella cheese baked on our crispy crust. Simple, delicious, and always satisfying from Goodfellas Pizza.

14” Three Cheese Pizza

Elevate the classic with extra flavor! We combine fresh mozzarella, provolone, and parmesan cheeses for a rich, savory experience only at Goodfellas.

14” Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Bold and zesty! Features tender Chicken tossed in our tangy Buffalo Sauce, fresh mozzarella, and finished with authentic Blue Cheese Crumbles. A fiery favorite at Goodfellas Pizza.

14 " House Special Pizza

A complete flavor package with Beef, Ham, Italian Sausage, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, and Black Olives. A true traditional combo that the Goodfellas kitchen does best.

14” Vegetarian Pizza

A fresh, garden-topped pizza featuring Onions, Peppers, Mushrooms, Black & Green Olives, Tomatoes, and Feta Cheese. The crisp, delicious choice at Goodfellas Pizza.

14" Goodfellas Special Pizza

The boss of all pies! This signature pizza is loaded with Beef, Ham, Italian Sausage, Onions, Olives, Tomatoes, and Feta Cheese. It's the ultimate, fully-loaded pie—only from Goodfellas Pizza!

14" Steak and Cheese

A Philly-inspired pie! Topped with thinly sliced, Marinated Steak, caramelized onions, and a blend of Mozzarella and Provolone Cheese. A savory masterpiece from Goodfellas.

14" Combination (3 Toppings) Pizza

Your pie, your way! Choose any three of our Goodfellas premium toppings to create the perfect personalized pizza.

14" Pepperoni Pizza

Generous slices of bold Pepperoni layered over our house sauce and cheese. A universal favorite, perfectly cooked every time by Goodfellas Pizza.

14" Super Hawaiian Pizza

A bold debate starter! Topped with savory Ham, sliced Pepperoni, and chunks of sweet Pineapple. Find out why this is a surprisingly delicious favorite at Goodfellas.

Cheese Calzone

Our huge, half-moon dough pocket stuffed with a blend of creamy Ricotta and melted Mozzarella cheeses. Simple, satisfying, and served with a side of our rich Marinara.

Chicken Calzone

A hearty meal inside a golden crust! Grilled, seasoned Chicken combined with creamy Ricotta and mozzarella cheese. This Goodfellas Calzone is a satisfying, savory delight.

Sausage Calzone

Crumbled, Italian sausage mixed with creamy Ricotta and mozzarella, baked inside a fresh dough pocket. A classic flavor combination done right by Goodfellas Pizza.

Spinach and Feta Calzone

A flavorful vegetarian option! Fresh Spinach and bold, salty Feta Cheese are folded with mozzarella and Ricotta. A sophisticated and delicious flavor profile from Goodfellas.

Combination Calzone

Choose any three premium Goodfellas toppings to be baked inside a pillow of Ricotta and mozzarella cheese. Create your ultimate Calzone masterpiece today!

Sweet and Tangy

A perfect balance of sweet tropical fruit and a zesty vinegary tang. A bright, mouthwatering option from Goodfellas Pizza.

Sweet Chill

A Thai-inspired sweet heat that is vibrant, sticky, and slightly spicy. A delicious, unique flavor at Goodfellas Pizza.

Mild

All the great flavor of our classic hot sauce, but dialed down to a pleasing warmth. A great starter sauce from Goodfellas.

Garlic Parm

Rich, buttery garlic and salty Parmesan cheese, creating a powerfully savory coating. A decadent choice for your Goodfellas wings.

Honey Hot Lemon Pepper

A Jacksonville signature! Our Honey Hot flavor elevated with the zesty, savory punch of Lemon Pepper. A must-try Goodfellas Pizza wing flavor.

Lemon Pepper

A zesty, tangy, and savory dry rub that delivers bright flavor. A highly-addictive, classic choice on any Goodfellas Pizza wing platter.

Lemon Pepper Wet

The Jacksonville staple! Our classic, tangy Lemon Pepper seasoning is mixed with a rich, buttery sauce to coat every nook and cranny of your wing. Juicy, zesty, and incredibly savory—a true Goodfellas Pizza favorite.

Hot

Our standard, but satisfying, level of heat. A classic fiery flavor for those who like their Goodfellas wings with a kick.

Honey Hot

The ultimate sweet-and-spicy combo. Our signature hot sauce is mellowed and enriched with natural honey. A top-selling Goodfellas blend!

Jerk

A bold, aromatic Caribbean favorite. This sauce features a complex blend of fiery scotch bonnet peppers, allspice, and herbs. A deep, spicy, and satisfying flavor that creates the legendary Goodfellas Jerk Wings.

BBQ

A rich, smoky, and classic barbecue glaze. A comforting, savory choice that's always a hit at Goodfellas Pizza.

Louisiana Hot

A simple, classic hot sauce made with aged cayenne peppers, butter, and vinegar. It offers a clean, traditional heat and tangy flavor. Perfect for those who love authentic, classic buffalo spice on their Goodfellas wings.

Teriyaki

A sweet and savory glaze with a hint of ginger and soy. An irresistible, umami-packed flavor for your Goodfellas wings.

Hot Lemon Pepper

The best of both worlds—our classic heat meets the bright, zesty dry rub of Lemon Pepper. A bold, spicy favorite at Goodfellas.

Fried Hard

Not a sauce, but a cooking style! We fry your wings extra crispy until they're golden brown and shatteringly crunchy. The perfect texture for absorbing any of our Goodfellas sauces or enjoying plain!

Chicken Philly w/Fries and Drink

Thinly sliced, seasoned chicken grilled with sweet onions and peppers, then topped with melted white American cheese. A hot, fresh, and savory sub from Goodfellas Pizza.

Meatball Sub w/Fries and Drink

Hearty, savory meatballs simmered in our rich Marinara Sauce and topped with a blanket of melted cheese. A satisfying and saucy classic from Goodfellas.

Philly Cheese Steak w/Fries and Drink

The authentic taste of Philly! Grilled steak, caramelized onions, and melted cheese, all packed into a warm sub roll. It's the king of subs at Goodfellas Pizza.

Chicken Parm Sub w/Fries and Drink

Tender, breaded chicken breast smothered in our house-made Marinara Sauce and covered in melted mozzarella cheese on a toasted sub roll. A classic Italian-American favorite, served the Goodfellas way.

Virgin Pasta

A simple and flavorful pasta dish with your choice of noodles, tossed in our slow-simmered Goodfellas Marinara Sauce. A classic for traditionalists.

Rasta Pasta

A vibrant and flavorful specialty pasta featuring our creamy, rich sauce, a blend of colorful vegetables, and a signature mix of savory spices. A truly unique and satisfying dish from Goodfellas Pizza!

Chicken Alfredo

Tender slices of grilled chicken and fettuccine pasta, all swimming in a velvety, house-made Alfredo Sauce. A decadent and comforting favorite, done the rich Goodfellas way.

Cobb Salad

The ultimate loaded salad. We pile fresh lettuce, ripe tomatoes, diced bacon, chunks of diced chicken, and bold Blue Cheese Crumbles. It’s a filling and flavorful favorite from Goodfellas Pizza!

Fried Tenders Salad

A satisfying salad featuring crisp lettuce, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, and cucumbers, topped with tender, golden-brown Fried Chicken. Get your fresh fix and your comfort food fix in one with Goodfellas!

3 Cheese

Our house blend of Mozzarella, Provolone, and Parmesan. Upgrade your cheese experience for a richer flavor profile on any pie.

Bacon

Crispy, chopped pieces of salty, irresistible smoked bacon. A welcome, smoky crunch on any Goodfellas Pizza or Stromboli.

Black Olives

Sliced, mild, and buttery black olives. A Mediterranean staple that adds a salty, savory layer to any Goodfellas combination.

Bananna Peppers

Sliced, mild yellow peppers that add a bright, tangy pop and a little bit of heat. A unique, zesty favorite.

Blue Cheese

Rich, tangy, and pungent crumbles of Blue Cheese. A classic complement to our Goodfellas Wings and a key ingredient in our Cobb Salad.

Chicken

Tender, all-white grilled chicken breast pieces. Lean, flavorful, and great on our Buffalo Chicken or any custom pizza.

Ham

Thinly sliced, savory, and tender cooked ham. A perfect pairing with pineapple on our Super Hawaiian or added to any meaty creation.

Italian Sausage

Crumbled, perfectly seasoned pork sausage with fennel and herbs, adding a rich, aromatic flavor to any Goodfellas pie.

Jalpenoes

Thinly sliced, fiery jalapeños that bring a significant, fresh heat to your custom Goodfellas Pizza.

Mushrooms

Sliced, earthy mushrooms that absorb the rich flavors of the sauce and cheese. A classic vegetable topping.

Bell Peppers

Fresh, colorful strips of crisp Green Bell Pepper that add a refreshing, sweet crunch to your custom Goodfellas pie.

Pepperoni

Slices of savory, smoky, and slightly spicy cured meat that cups up and crisps beautifully. The classic pizza topping, done right by Goodfellas.

Steak

Thinly sliced, seasoned steak pieces, marinated and cooked until tender. The star topping of our decadent Steak & Cheese Pizza.

Tomatoes

Sliced, juicy red tomatoes that add a burst of fresh, ripe flavor to our Goodfellas salads and subs.

Onions

Sliced yellow onions that caramelize beautifully under the heat, providing a savory depth to any Goodfellas Pizza.

Feta Cheese

Crumbled, bold, and salty white feta cheese. A signature topping on our Greek Salad and a zesty upgrade for any pizza or calzone.

Green Olives

Sliced, tangy, and salty green olives. A bolder flavor choice that adds a wonderful brine to our Vegetarian and Goodfellas Special pizzas.

Spinach

Fresh, bright green leaf spinach. A healthy and flavorful addition to any pizza or our Spinach & Feta Calzone.

Extra Cheese

Double the deliciousness! Add an extra blanket of our premium mozzarella cheese to any pizza, calzone, or sub.

Pepperchini Peppers

Mild, tangy, and zesty whole golden peppers. A delicious and colorful addition to our Greek Salad and other dishes.

Lettuce

A blend of fresh, crisp green leaf and Romaine lettuce. The perfect foundation for any delicious Goodfellas salad.

Pinapples

Sweet, juicy chunks of tropical pineapple. A controversial yet delicious pairing with ham or pepperoni on your Goodfellas pizza.

Beef Sausage

Finely ground, seasoned beef sausage that adds a savory depth and texture. A favorite addition to our fully-loaded Goodfellas Special.

Blue Cheese

Dip your Goodfellas wings in a side of bold Blue Cheese dressing.

Salad Dressing

Finish your Goodfellas salad just the way you like it. Choose from: Golden Italian, Blue Cheese, Honey Mustard, Ranch, or Caesar.

Small Fries

A small order of our perfectly seasoned, crispy French fries. The ideal salty side to any Goodfellas combo or sandwich.

Large Fries

A generous portion of our hot, golden, and crispy French fries. Great for sharing with the whole table while you wait for your main course at Goodfellas Pizza.